Gordon S. Wood Quote
Allowing unelected judges to declare laws enacted by popularly elected legislatures unconstitutional and invalid seemed flagrantly inconsistent with free popular government. Such judicial usurpation, said Richard Dobbs Spaight, delegate to the Constitutional Convention from North Carolina, was absurd and operated as an absolute negative on the proceedings of the Legislature, which no judiciary ought ever to possess. Instead of being governed by their representatives in the assembly, the people would be subject to the will of a few individuals in the court, who united in their own persons the legislative and judiciary powers, making the courts more despotic than the Roman decemvirate or of any monarchy in Europe.
Allowing unelected judges to declare laws enacted by popularly elected legislatures unconstitutional and invalid seemed flagrantly inconsistent with free popular government. Such judicial usurpation, said Richard Dobbs Spaight, delegate to the Constitutional Convention from North Carolina, was absurd and operated as an absolute negative on the proceedings of the Legislature, which no judiciary ought ever to possess. Instead of being governed by their representatives in the assembly, the people would be subject to the will of a few individuals in the court, who united in their own persons the legislative and judiciary powers, making the courts more despotic than the Roman decemvirate or of any monarchy in Europe.
Related Quotes
About Gordon S. Wood
